In which my cop trial sensibilities and legal analysis is quite generally correct. I’ve said recently, cop thumper lawyers almost always take their cop thumper clients to trial but this might be a case where cop thumper lawyers assent to a reliable 15 year sentence such that they can get it. The news today: https://www.fox9.com/news/ex-minneapolis-police-officer-chauvin-was-in-talks-to-plead-guilty-before-arrest
If prosecution / defense couldn’t get a deal done, it’s because of the spread of the presumptive / suggested sentence they wanted to bring to the judge. I assume the prosecution is going to want say 15-20 years (Mohammed Noor / Michael Slager prison time) and Chauvin’s defense wants 5. Chauvin’s defense may have been prudent in not committing to 15 years right now such that there’s a lot of clock to run before the trial, but… they should and probably do understand he’s doing way more than 5 years.
Anyway, about me being right, and a calibrated observer / analyst of this stuff, as somewhat a crank conservative by temperament… I made a rare visit to “the” conservative blog in town the other day, Bitch Merg’s Crap in the Dark. He’s got say 20 commenters in this age of blogs being dead, and it’s a total circle jerk of racist misanthropes who want to believe A) the strangulation is a justifiable use of force because Floyd is a big black (ex) felon and B) Chauvin will get off because Ellison is running the case, and Ellison is an incompetant race hustler […and incompetant because he’s black…]. They weren’t having any of me saying Chauvin is going to get convicted cuz Facebook video of 9 minute strangulation. So, F em, those guys are incorrigible dicks.
I watched Keith Ellison appear on Fox with Chris Wallace the Sunday morning before he got the case from the county and A) he was completely responsible in temperament and analysis and B) at that point he was absolutely persuasive as at ease that Freeman would run the case fine at the county level. I do imagine it was Walz who subsequently stepped in to “ask” Freeman to request the AG assistance that kicked the case up to the state level. Anyway, Ellison. It is the man meeting his moment in life. He was a controversial commie firebrand as a younger man, yes… he seems pretty Fing solid, professional, and institutional as a 55 yo or whatever he is. Reminds me of Barack Obama that way.
Earl Gray is actually Thomas Lane’s lawyer, and it’s been an erratic start. He went on CNN to do some legal TV, and got his ass handed to him over his argument that the strangulation wasn’t a big deal such that the bystanders gave their okey dokey by not intervening https://twitter.com/dbrauer/status/1270198022790500352
Worth noting that Gray’s success over the years has always entailed victim smearing. He’s defended U football gang rapers and called their victims sluts who liked gang bangs, defended Yanez and called Philando and his girlfriend pot smoking low lifes on welfare… So this, is that. But besides being about 76 now, Earl’s act is probably not going to work in this case cuz ya know, 9 minute strangulation on video.
It is a curious thing that Gray does media at all while the other lawyers don’t (Tom Plunkett – Keung, Eric Nelson – Chauvin)
Eric Nelson did replace Tom Kelly as Chauvin’s lawyer last week. https://www.usnews.com/news/top-news/articles/2020-06-03/exclusive-former-police-officer-accused-of-killing-george-floyd-gets-new-lawyer Thing is apparently, the union has a list of local super lawyers who will take the cop cases with whatever invoice arrangement they have, and they do it in some rotating order. The story is Kelly was up when Chauvin was charged, but he’s out now because of “medical issues”. Uh, sure, if by medical issue you also mean septuagenarian like Gray. These cases are not for 61, 65, 71, 76 year old practicing defense attorneys. Nelson is under 45 and has conducted some good defenses (Amy Senser, the fishing hole killer there up north).
Tom Lane has a PayPal go fund me for his bail https://wccoradio.radio.com/articles/family-of-officer-charged-with-aiding-floyds-murder-seeks This should be his bail, ya figure his defense invoice is paid for by the unions legal insurance.
Lane notes on his page he’s being treated with a lack of proportion with the $1M bail yada yada. Here I will deploy the idiom about playing sympathetic music on the world’s smallest violin… Ya know, you read stories about violent police encounters, and the thin bluer liners will invariably dismiss the victims and litter the below the story comment threads with “play stupid games, win stupid prizes”. So there’s that too, Officer Lane “Play stupid games, win stupid prizes.”
Do I find it a compelling observation that Thomas Lane and JA Keung might be grossly over punished in this, over punished way out of proportion to their actual malevolence? I do but… play stupid games, win stupid prizes. Tough shit, Tom.
Medium article by anonymous ex-cop that says everything I already believed about the profession https://medium.com/@OfcrACab/confessions-of-a-former-bastard-cop-bb14d17bc759 Big thing: the lying that is a feature of the ecosystem like nitrogen is a feature of our atmosphere.
At trial I see this is as something that gets suppressed due to it being hearsay and overly prejudicial https://twitter.com/CBSEveningNews/status/1270485898585690112 But such that it might be true it speaks, as I’ve said, to the motivation for excessive force being not wanting to chance losing a physical confrontation with a strong black man.